Health insurance: what you pay and what it could return
Health insurance helps pay for medical care and caps what you could owe in a bad year. Without it, one hospital stay could cost more than most people have in savings. It's less like an investment and more like a shield, but a calculator is still useful for seeing what coverage costs and what kind of year it would take for your plan to pay for itself.
The calculator compares two plans for real. Your plan costs $750 a month with a $1,500 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $6,000 out-of-pocket max. A year with $5,000 of medical bills costs $11,200 in all: $9,000 in premiums and $2,200 in care. The other plan, an HSA-eligible plan at $600 a month with a $3,400 deductible and a $7,000 max, costs $9,600 in the same year, after $1,320 of tax saved on $4,400 of HSA deposits. It saves $1,600.
Check more than one kind of year. In a healthy year, the other plan saves $3,120, because you pay only premiums. In a heavy year that hits both maximums, it still saves $2,120. That's because its premiums are $1,800 a year lower and the HSA saves $1,320, while its out-of-pocket max is only $1,000 higher. The chart shows each plan's yearly cost at every level of medical bills, and the table below it lists them side by side.
The HSA is worth counting. Deposits come out of your taxable income, so at a 30% combined tax rate, $4,400 saves $1,320. That money stays yours, grows tax-free and can pay for care later. Without the HSA, the other plan saves just $280 in a $5,000 year. At $700 a month with no HSA, the plans cost the same at about $2,250 of bills, and your plan wins above that. Check networks too, because an out-of-network doctor can make either plan cost far more.
The first sentence above compares 10 years of premiums with your claims. The example pays $750 a month, or $90,000 over 10 years, against five $20,000 claims, an 11.1% return. Those are round illustrations. If you buy your own plan, you may qualify for savings on HealthCare.gov based on your income. This calculator can't replace your plan's documents or a licensed agent.