Homeowners insurance: what you pay and what it could return
Homeowners insurance pays to repair or rebuild your home and replace your belongings after a covered loss, such as a fire or a windstorm. It also covers liability if someone is hurt on your property and you're found responsible. Mortgage lenders almost always require it. Unlike an investment, you hope never to see a return, because a payout means something has gone badly wrong.
Enter your monthly premium, how many claims you expect over 10 years and the average value of a claim. The calculator totals 120 months of premiums and compares them with your claims. The example pays $250 a month, or $30,000 over 10 years, against one $78,000 claim with a $1,000 deductible. You pay $31,000 and get $77,000 back, a return of 148.4%. Change the claim count to zero and you'll see the much more likely outcome: $30,000 spent for peace of mind.
The useful question isn't ROI but whether your coverage is right. Your dwelling limit should reflect what it would cost to rebuild, which can differ a lot from your home's market value, since market value includes land. Ask for replacement-cost coverage on the house and belongings rather than actual cash value, which subtracts depreciation. Standard policies usually exclude flood damage, and often earthquakes too.
Your deductible counts on every claim, and the calculator tells you what doubling it would take. In the example, a $2,000 deductible adds $1,000 to the one claim, so it only pays off if it cuts your premium by more than $100 a year. The table below runs the same math for common deductible changes. Keep the higher deductible in savings before you switch.
How a higher homeowners deductible pays off
A higher deductible costs you the difference on each claim. It pays off when the yearly premium savings beat that difference spread over how often you claim.
| Switch | Extra you pay per claim | Savings needed: 1 claim in 10 years | 1 claim in 5 years | 1 claim in 3 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500 to $1,000 | $500 | $50 a year | $100 a year | $167 a year |
| $1,000 to $2,500 | $1,500 | $150 a year | $300 a year | $500 a year |
| $2,500 to $5,000 | $2,500 | $250 a year | $500 a year | $833 a year |