Rent vs. Buy Calculator: Bay Area

Buying a home in with down at instead of renting for a month, and staying years, leaves renting ahead by $743,481.07.

San Francisco Bay Area: typical home $1,234,000 and typical rent $3,550 (Zillow, September 2026), property tax 1.1% (Census ACS 2024), 7.11% average 30-year rate (Freddie Mac, November 12, 2026). New buyers in California pay about 1.1% under Prop 13, more than the 0.73% average owners pay.

Start over
Year by year

Free calculator by ROI.fyi

Bay Area housing market at a glance

Bay AreaUnited States
Typical home value$1,234,000$366,000
Typical rent$3,550$1,930
Price-to-rent ratio29.015.8
Property tax rate1.1%0.89%
Home values, last 12 months+2.3%+1.2%
Home values per year, last 10 years+4.5%+5.9%
Rent per year, last 5 years+4.7%+4.0%
Largest drop in home values-32.4% (April 2006 to February 2012)-24.2% (April 2007 to February 2012)
Households that rent45.1%34.7%

Sources: Zillow Home Value Index and Observed Rent Index (September 2026) for home values and rents. US Census Bureau American Community Survey 2024 for property tax and households that rent, with 1.1% for a new California buyer. Bay Area figures combine the San Francisco and San Jose metros, weighted by households.

Net worth by how long you stay

A typical $1,234,000 home with 20% down at 7.11%, against renting for $3,550 and investing the difference.

StayIf you buyIf you rentAhead
3 years$311,988$561,236Renting by $249,248
5 years$414,360$777,278Renting by $362,917
7 years$525,269$1,022,268Renting by $496,999
10 years$709,570$1,453,051Renting by $743,481
15 years$1,073,364$2,381,932Renting by $1,308,569
20 years$1,525,838$3,662,795Renting by $2,136,957
30 years$2,815,527$7,888,327Renting by $5,072,799

Sources: Zillow (September 2026) for price and rent, US Census Bureau American Community Survey 2024 for property tax, Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (November 12, 2026) for the rate. Other inputs are the calculator's defaults: 3% yearly growth in prices and rents, 7% on invested savings, 1% upkeep, $1,500 insurance, 3% to buy and 6% to sell.

Is it better to rent or buy in the Bay Area?

Right now, renting comes out ahead over 10 years, by about $743,481. A typical home in the Bay Area is worth $1,234,000, and typical rent is $3,550 a month, per Zillow's September 2026 figures. With 20% down at the 7.11% average 30-year rate, the loan payment alone is $6,641 a month. Add 1.1% property tax, 1% upkeep and insurance, and owning costs $8,925 in the first month, $5,375 more than rent.

The price-to-rent ratio tells most of the story. A typical home here costs 29.0 years of rent, against 15.8 for the US. Above 20, renting usually wins, because each dollar of rent buys far more home than each dollar of mortgage, tax and upkeep. With these numbers, buying doesn't pull ahead even after 30 years.

Here is what it would take for buying to match renting over 10 years, one change at a time. Rent would need to be about $7,405 a month. Or the home would need to cost about $581,880. Or your mortgage rate would need to be about 1.08%. Or home prices would need to rise about 7.5% a year instead of 3%.

The past 10 years were good to owners. Home values in the Bay Area rose 4.5% a year, and rents rose 4.7% a year over the last five. If both kept that pace for the next 10 years, renting would come out $481,302 ahead. Nobody can promise that. Prices here fell 32.4% from April 2006 to February 2012. Over the last 12 months, values rose 2.3%.

Two cautions about these figures. Zillow's typical rent covers apartments as well as houses, so the typical rental is often smaller than the typical home. If you'd rent a place like the one you'd buy, enter that rent above. And property tax in California depends on when you bought. Under Prop 13, a new buyer pays about 1% of the price plus local levies, so we use 1.1%. Owners who bought years ago pay less, which is why the Census average here is 0.73%.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to rent or buy in the Bay Area?

Month to month, renting is cheaper. Owning a typical home costs about $8,925 in the first month against $3,550 in rent. Over time, rent rises while most of a fixed-rate payment doesn't, and owners build equity. That's why we compare net worth, not just monthly costs. After 10 years, renting is ahead by about $743,481.

How long do you need to stay in the Bay Area for buying to pay off?

Longer than 30 years with today's typical price, rent and rate. Buying and selling cost about 9% of the price together, or $111,060 on a typical home here. Early payments are mostly interest, so equity builds slowly at first. A lower price, a lower rate or a higher rent shortens the wait. Try your own numbers above.

What is the price-to-rent ratio in the Bay Area?

About 29.0. That's the typical home value, $1,234,000, divided by a year of typical rent, $42,600. The US figure is 15.8. Ratios under 15 tend to favor buying and ratios over 20 tend to favor renting. The ratio leaves out rates, taxes and how long you stay, which the calculator includes.

How much income do you need to buy a typical home in the Bay Area?

About $383,000 a year, if you follow the common rule of spending no more than 28% of gross income on housing. That's based on $8,925 a month for the loan, property tax, insurance and upkeep, with 20% down, which is $246,800 here. Lenders often allow more, and debts such as car loans lower what they'll approve.

How much is a down payment in the Bay Area?

On a typical $1,234,000 home, 20% down is $246,800, 10% is $123,400 and 3.5% is $43,190. Closing costs add roughly $37,020 more. Putting less than 20% down usually means paying mortgage insurance until you reach 20% equity.

What is the property tax rate in the Bay Area?

A new buyer pays about 1.1% of the purchase price in most of California: the 1% Prop 13 base plus local bonds and assessments. On a typical home here, that's about $13,574 a year. The average owner pays 0.73% of value, because assessments rise at most 2% a year until a home sells.

Have home prices in the Bay Area ever fallen?

Yes. Prices here fell 32.4% from April 2006 to February 2012. Over the last 10 years they rose 4.5% a year, and over 20 years 3.3% a year, which includes the 2008 crash. Our calculator assumes 3% a year. A short stay during a fall can leave a buyer owing more than the home would sell for after costs.

How fast are rents rising in the Bay Area?

Typical rent rose 10.8% over the last 12 months and 4.7% a year over the last five years, per Zillow. The calculator assumes 3% a year. Faster rent growth favors buying, since a fixed-rate loan payment doesn't rise. At the 5-year pace for both rent and prices, renting would be $481,302 ahead after 10 years.

What mortgage rate makes buying worth it in the Bay Area?

About 1.08% for a 10-year stay, with a typical home and rent. Today's average is 7.11%. Points, credits and a shorter loan term all change the math, and you could refinance if rates fall, which the calculator doesn't assume.

What share of Bay Area households rent?

About 45.1%, against 34.7% nationwide, per the Census Bureau's 2024 survey. The median gross rent the Census reports, $2,545, is lower than Zillow's typical asking rent, $3,550, because it includes long-term tenants whose rent hasn't caught up with the market.

Does the 5% rule say to rent or buy in the Bay Area?

The 5% rule takes 5% of the home price a year, for tax, upkeep and the return you give up, and compares it with rent. For a typical $1,234,000 home, that's $5,142 a month. Typical rent is $3,550, so the rule says renting is the better deal. It ignores your mortgage rate and how long you'll stay, so use the calculator for the full comparison.

More real estate calculators

Buy a home

Rent or buy, then the monthly payment and what the home earns you.

Invest

Cash flow, cap rate and return on a rental, a short-term rental or a flip.

Own & improve

Borrow against your equity, insure it and add solar.