Should you take the pension or the lump sum?
Many employers offer a choice when you retire: a monthly pension for life, or a single lump sum you can invest yourself. Enter the monthly pension, the age it starts, how long you plan for, the return you could earn and the lump sum offered. We work out what the pension is worth in today's money, the return the lump sum would need to match it, and how long the lump sum would last if you paid yourself the same checks.
In the example, a $2,000 monthly pension from 65 to 85 is worth $307,133 today at a 5% return. The lump sum offered is $350,000, so it's worth about $42,900 more on those assumptions. To match the pension to 85, the lump sum only has to earn 3.42% a year. Paying yourself $2,000 a month from it at 5%, it lasts until about 90.
The answer turns on how long you live. Planning to 90, the pension is worth $347,347 and the lump sum needs 4.92%. Planning to 95, the pension is worth $378,856 and the lump sum needs 5.75%, more than many retirees earn safely. The pension's checks add up to the $350,000 lump sum by about 79 and a half, and everything after that is extra. A pension that rises 2% a year is worth $361,431 at 85.
A pension is longevity insurance: the checks never stop, and you can't outlive them. A lump sum gives you control, flexibility and something to leave to heirs, but you carry the market and longevity risk. Check whether the pension is insured by the PBGC, whether it has a survivor option for a spouse, and how it's taxed. To see the pension inside a full plan, enter it as income on our retirement calculator.