Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Buying a home in with down at instead of renting for a month, and staying years, leaves buying ahead by $31,085.78.

Start over
Year by year

Free calculator by ROI.fyi

Rent vs. buy by location

Today, buying a typical home beats renting over 10 years in 1 of the 50 largest US metros, with 20% down at the 7.11% average mortgage rate. Buying wins by the most in New Orleans, $10,905. San Jose favors renters most, by $1,023,956. For the US as a whole, a $366,000 home against $1,930 rent leaves renting $53,846 ahead. Pick a metro to load its numbers above.

MetroTypical homeTypical rentPrice-to-rentOwning, first monthAhead after 10 yearsBuying pulls ahead
New York, NY$731,000$3,55017.2$5,606Rent by $222,413Not in 30 years
Los Angeles, CA$950,000$2,93027.0$6,900Rent by $539,289Not in 30 years
Chicago, IL$356,000$2,16013.7$2,901Rent by $57,000Not in 30 years
Dallas, TX$358,000$1,66018.0$2,780Rent by $129,160Not in 30 years
Houston, TX$303,000$1,64015.4$2,374Rent by $67,759Not in 30 years
Washington, DC$570,000$2,41019.7$4,095Rent by $187,785Not in 30 years
Philadelphia, PA$386,000$1,90016.9$2,955Rent by $110,050Not in 30 years
Miami, FL$477,000$2,65015.0$3,419Rent by $33,052Year 18
Atlanta, GA$376,000$1,84017.0$2,716Rent by $77,365Not in 30 years
Boston, MA$726,000$2,99020.2$5,248Rent by $261,688Not in 30 years
Phoenix, AZ$441,000$1,72021.4$3,013Rent by $142,091Not in 30 years
San Francisco, CA$1,120,000$3,44027.1$8,112Rent by $634,729Not in 30 years
Riverside, CA$580,000$2,53019.1$4,261Rent by $194,611Not in 30 years
Detroit, MI$264,000$1,51014.6$2,047Rent by $38,836Not in 30 years
Seattle, WA$720,000$2,25026.7$5,110Rent by $378,910Not in 30 years
Minneapolis, MN$388,000$1,74018.6$2,882Rent by $126,204Not in 30 years
San Diego, CA$927,000$2,97026.0$6,736Rent by $505,351Not in 30 years
Tampa, FL$357,000$1,99014.9$2,564Rent by $23,595Year 17
Denver, CO$555,000$1,90024.3$3,824Rent by $236,998Not in 30 years
Baltimore, MD$397,000$1,94017.1$2,913Rent by $91,374Not in 30 years
St. Louis, MO$273,000$1,43015.9$2,076Rent by $57,676Not in 30 years
Orlando, FL$383,000$1,93016.5$2,742Rent by $63,287Not in 30 years
Charlotte, NC$381,000$1,73018.4$2,696Rent by $93,496Not in 30 years
San Antonio, TX$274,000$1,42016.1$2,150Rent by $73,694Not in 30 years
Portland, OR$539,000$1,80025.0$3,852Rent by $265,850Not in 30 years
Sacramento, CA$573,000$2,27021.0$4,211Rent by $236,784Not in 30 years
Pittsburgh, PA$228,000$1,47012.9$1,772Rent by $1,853Year 11
Cincinnati, OH$306,000$1,52016.8$2,315Rent by $78,545Not in 30 years
Austin, TX$414,000$1,60021.6$3,191Rent by $207,006Not in 30 years
Las Vegas, NV$423,000$1,73020.4$2,923Rent by $127,206Not in 30 years
Kansas City, MO$325,000$1,53017.7$2,437Rent by $95,723Not in 30 years
Columbus, OH$327,000$1,52017.9$2,498Rent by $108,983Not in 30 years
Indianapolis, IN$292,000$1,53015.9$2,142Rent by $46,315Not in 30 years
Cleveland, OH$250,000$1,44014.5$1,995Rent by $45,742Not in 30 years
San Jose, CA$1,524,000$3,81033.3$10,994Rent by $1,023,956Not in 30 years
Nashville, TN$449,000$1,80020.8$3,095Rent by $140,719Not in 30 years
Virginia Beach, VA$371,000$1,89016.4$2,681Rent by $62,256Not in 30 years
Providence, RI$522,000$2,17020.0$3,826Rent by $193,676Not in 30 years
Jacksonville, FL$351,000$1,68017.4$2,526Rent by $77,476Not in 30 years
Milwaukee, WI$384,000$1,55020.6$2,921Rent by $171,451Not in 30 years
Oklahoma City, OK$243,000$1,38014.7$1,817Rent by $24,311Year 24
Raleigh, NC$428,000$1,67021.4$3,020Rent by $156,526Not in 30 years
Memphis, TN$242,000$1,39014.5$1,764Rent by $12,206Year 15
Richmond, VA$392,000$1,71019.1$2,793Rent by $113,541Not in 30 years
Louisville, KY$279,000$1,34017.4$2,045Rent by $67,352Not in 30 years
New Orleans, LA$257,000$1,58013.6$1,853Buy by $10,905Year 8
Salt Lake City, UT$559,000$1,64028.4$3,837Rent by $288,615Not in 30 years
Hartford, CT$399,000$2,00016.6$3,183Rent by $132,091Not in 30 years
Buffalo, NY$287,000$1,45016.5$2,334Rent by $100,685Not in 30 years
Birmingham, AL$261,000$1,40015.5$1,858Rent by $23,805Year 22

Sources: Home values and rents are Zillow's typical (mid-tier) figures for September 2026. Property tax is what owners pay on average, from the Census Bureau's 2024 American Community Survey, with California set to the 1.1% a new buyer pays. Other assumptions match the calculator: 3% yearly growth in prices and rents, 7% on invested savings, 1% upkeep, $1,500 insurance, 3% to buy and 6% to sell. The typical rental is often smaller than the typical home, so compare against the rent for a place like the one you'd buy.

Is it better to rent or buy?

It depends on the price, the rent, your mortgage rate and above all how long you stay. Enter them above. The example compares a $400,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% against renting a similar place for $2,500 a month. Over 10 years, buying leaves you about $31,086 richer, and it pulls ahead in year 7. Before that, renting wins.

We compare the two fairly. Both sides start with the same cash. The buyer spends it on the down payment and about 3% in closing costs. The renter invests it instead, at 7% a year. Each month, whoever pays less invests the difference. Owning costs the loan payment plus property tax, upkeep and insurance, $2,848 in the first month here. At the end, the buyer sells and pays about 6% in selling costs. Then we compare net worth.

Time is the biggest factor. Buying and selling costs about 9% of the price in total, so a short stay rarely works. With these numbers, buying is $10,783 behind after 5 years but $97,255 ahead after 15. Rent matters too. At $2,200 a month, renting stays ahead even after 15 years. At $2,800, buying pulls ahead in year 4.

Choose "Edit them" to change the assumptions: home price growth, rent growth, what your savings earn, property tax, upkeep, insurance and transaction costs. Small changes add up over a decade. At 5.5% instead of 6.5%, buying is about $73,422 ahead after 10 years. If the renter's savings earn 5% rather than 7%, buying comes out $65,766 ahead. The result is only as good as these guesses, and it leaves out income taxes and the mortgage interest deduction.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do you need to stay for buying to beat renting?

Often five to seven years, but it depends on your numbers. Buying and later selling cost about 9% of the price, and early mortgage payments are mostly interest, so it takes time for equity and appreciation to catch up. In our example, buying pulls ahead in year 7. Change the years above to find your own break-even.

Is renting throwing money away?

No. Rent buys you a place to live, just as mortgage interest, property tax and upkeep do for an owner. None of those build equity. The real comparison is what each choice leaves you with after all costs. Renters who invest the money they'd otherwise put into a home can end up ahead, especially over shorter stays.

What is the 5% rule for renting vs. buying?

It's a quick check. Multiply the home price by 5% and divide by 12. If you can rent a similar home for less than that, renting may be the better deal. For a $400,000 home, that's $1,667 a month. The 5% is a rough total of property tax, upkeep and the return you give up on your money. Our calculator runs the full comparison instead.

What is the price-to-rent ratio?

It's the home price divided by a year's rent. A $400,000 home that rents for $2,500 a month has a ratio of about 13. Lower ratios, around 15 or under, tend to favor buying. Ratios above 20 tend to favor renting. It's a shortcut that ignores rates, taxes and how long you stay, so use it alongside the calculator.

How much does it cost to buy a home besides the price?

Closing costs usually run 2% to 5% of the price, covering lender fees, an appraisal, title insurance and taxes. You also pay property tax, insurance and upkeep every year. We assume 1.1% tax, 1% upkeep and $1,500 insurance. When you sell, agent fees and other costs often add up to 6% or more.

Does a higher mortgage rate favor renting?

Yes. A higher rate raises the monthly cost of owning, and that difference goes to the renter's investments. In our example, buying is about $31,086 ahead after 10 years at 6.5%, and about $73,422 ahead at 5.5%. If rates fall later, owners may be able to refinance, which this calculator doesn't assume.

Should I buy a house if I might move in a few years?

Usually it's risky. With our example numbers, buying is still about $10,783 behind renting after 5 years, because the costs of buying and selling haven't been recovered. If you may move, consider whether you'd keep the home and rent it out. Our rental property calculator can show whether that would pay.

How much down payment do I need to buy?

Many loans allow 3% to 5% down, and some government loans allow less. Putting less than 20% down usually means paying mortgage insurance until you reach 20% equity. A smaller down payment leaves more cash for the renter's side of the comparison to invest, which this calculator accounts for. Try different amounts above.

Do home prices always go up?

No. US home prices have risen over long periods, but they fell sharply from 2006 to 2012 in many areas. Local markets can be flat for years. We assume 3% a year, which you can change. At 4%, buying comes out about $76,013 ahead after 10 years in our example. At 0%, it's much less likely to win.

What does the renter do with the money they save?

We assume they invest it, starting with the down payment and closing costs, plus any month where owning costs more than rent. That's the key to a fair comparison. If you'd spend the difference instead, buying usually looks better, because a mortgage acts as forced savings through the principal you pay each month.

Are taxes included?

No. We leave out income taxes, including the mortgage interest deduction and taxes on investment gains. Most households take the standard deduction, so the mortgage interest deduction often doesn't help. Home sale profits up to $250,000, or $500,000 for married couples, are usually tax-free for a main home. Check IRS guidance for your situation.

More real estate calculators

Buy a home

Rent or buy, then the monthly payment and what the home earns you.

Invest

Cash flow, cap rate and return on a rental, a short-term rental or a flip.

Own & improve

Borrow against your equity, insure it and add solar.