Which has returned more, SCHD or VOO?
Over the last 10 years, VOO returned 14.9% a year and SCHD returned 13.4%, with dividends reinvested. So $10,000 in SCHD would be worth about $35,080 now, against $40,193 in VOO. Over 15 years, the longest stretch both have prices for, the yearly figures are 13.5% for SCHD and 14.8% for VOO. We use month-end prices through November 2026, adjusted for splits and dividends, before taxes and fees.
The ride matters as much as the result. SCHD's monthly returns swung about 13.7% a year, measured as annualized standard deviation, against 13.8% for VOO, so the two have been about equally bumpy. SCHD's largest fall from a high was 21.5%, from December 2019 to March 2020. VOO's was 23.9%, from December 2021 to September 2022.
Year by year, SCHD beat VOO in 4 of 14 full calendar years. SCHD's best year was 2013, at 32.9%, and VOO's was 2013, at 32.4%. Their worst years were 2018 for SCHD, at -5.6%, and 2022 for VOO, at -18.2%. Month to month, they moved in the same direction most of the time, with a correlation of 0.82. That difference is why some investors hold both: one can soften the other's bad stretches, though not always.
Buying a little each month narrows the gap from timing. Putting $100 a month into each for the last 10 years would have cost $12,000 and be worth about $24,661 in SCHD and $26,442 in VOO. These results are historical and hypothetical, and past performance doesn't indicate future results. A fund spreads your money across its holdings, but it still falls when they fall, as the drops above show. See each on its own on our SCHD calculator and VOO calculator.
How we compare SCHD and VOO
We line up both histories by month, starting November 2011, the first month both have prices. The calculator above runs any amount and period for SCHD, and shows the same money in VOO beside it. Price data from Alpha Vantage.